Hello, my name is Acacia and I am a book addict. I aim to have at least three picture book versions of every Bible story in my personal library, although five would be better. When I buy different versions of a story, I consider the text of the book, the illustrations of the book, and some nebulous other considerations I can’t fit into a category.
See Part I: Text and Part II: Illustrations for the earlier posts in this series.
Story in Pictures
Without the pictures, this book would be nothing. Either there are many small pictures illustrating a common theme (Love Is…), or the pictures form a clear narrative (Tim Ladwig’s The Lord’s Prayer), or both (Noah’s Ark by Peter Speir). These books are often wordless, or contain only a couple of words per page.
Made You Think
Here, the illustrations are unusual, and break out of the mold for this story.
The Nativity, by Julie Vivas. The juxtaposition of angels in combat boots and the verbatim KJV text is both startling and refreshing.
Psalm 23, by Tim Ladwig. Instead of literal sheep, the illustrations are of children. Instead of a wooden rod and staff, the artist drew a school crossing guard with a stop sign.
Interactive Book
Does the book have a flap to lift? A mouse to find hiding on each page? Can you sniff and smell? Does a cartoon character in the corner make wry commentary?
Shiny Touchy Smelly: Creation Story, by Joanna Bicknell. A board book, but four and five year olds still like it.
Noah’s Ark Pop Up, by Tim Dowley. A pretty impressive pop-up, with flaps to open, boats to move back and forth, and yes, things that pop-up.
Best of All Worlds
This is often what I settle for when I can’t find anything awesome. It tends to be a paraphrase that sticks reasonably close to Bible, with illustrations that are decent.
The Creation Story, illus. Norman Messenger. This combines realistic drawings with word-of-God text. Cool beans! I’m not just settling for this, I love it!
The Christmas Story, by Jane Werner. A Little Golden Book that sticks close to Bible. I’m not a fan of the lady angels in pretty dresses, since all the angels in the Bible are unisex or male, but the text is all right.